+5

Nurse Banned For Sweating Too Much

Nurse Banned For Sweating Too Much

United Press International

January 23, 2008

HULL, Quebec, Jan. 23 (UPI)—Quebec’s Ministry of Labor arbitration tribunal upheld a hospital’s decision to fire an obese operating room nurse because she would sweat excessively.

... The Hull Hospital in western Quebec fired the unidentified woman in December 2005, and she challenged it with the province’s labor ministry, the Ottawa Citizen reported.

Hospital lawyer Charles Saucier told the newspaper there were medical grounds in the firing.

“She weighed more than 300 pounds and had a problem with excessive sweating,” he said. “An operating room is supposed to be a sterile environment without bacteria. There was an excessive amount of bacteria in the operating room air because of her sweating, creating a risk of infection.”

He said the hospital tried to accommodate the nurse and she changed her clothing frequently during surgery, but her clothing remained wet.

Her union has 30 days to appeal the arbitration ruling, the report said.


Courtesy of © 2008, YellowBrix, Inc.


+5
  • Photo-2_max50

    marinaarias

    9 months ago

    16 comments

    I believe that the issue of obesity and/or sweating should have been a factor in hiring a nurse in the first place. If that is such a serious health issue, than every applicant who is overweight or sweats profusely, should be denied employment. Is there a weight limit for nurses? Is there some sort of test given to determine the amount of sweat that is allowed? If this TRUELY puts patients at risk, then there needs to be a weight limit and testing for sweating put in place. This is inhumane! I hope that she fights this to the end.

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    oncall

    9 months ago

    6 comments

    Perhaps there is more to the story. Once we had a very obese clerk in our dep't and the nurses station smelled so bad no one could work in there. I know she was clean but the smell just couldn't go away. Then one day she was gone and so was the chair she sat in. Food for thought.

  • Peachy_bill_max50

    whcernan

    9 months ago

    2 comments

    I don't think that everyone should jump to the conclusion that the sweating and obesity are related. Concentrate on the sweating alone. I agree with Pamelab. Who wants someone sweating into their incisions while they're in surgery? We wash our hands all the time, great, but if we're dripping sweat in the OR, that's bad. In a hospital, germs from every person in there are on your body. I wouldn't want to sweat those germs into the body cavity of a patient.

  • Notme_max50

    icunurse409

    9 months ago

    12 comments

    Perhaps they should have transferred her to another department/position, one where she was less apt to sweat so much, in lieu of firing her. May have saved them a headache and she would still have a job. I used to work in surgery and at that time, weighed 105 llbs. Whether you are donned in gear and assisting or running back and forth as a circulator getting the surgeon what he needs, and although the temp is freezing, we all got hot, we have all sweat a little. Did they not have a position in the GI lab or medical records doing chart audits, etc. ??? Firing should be the last resort. Shows you don't care about people after she got up every morning and came to work and was a dedicated employee. I would have given her a membership to weight watchers and given her deadline to lose some weight before firing her. Is there not a nursing shortage in Canada? )-: Just remember nurse, when you get kicked out one door, there is another door open to you. It may be a hidden blessing!

  • Dsc09779_max50

    Pamelab

    9 months ago

    12 comments

    If u or a loved one had to go to THAT hospital 4 surgery
    knowing what u know about THAT nurse,would u want her to assist
    with the surgery?

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    dmazment

    9 months ago

    896 comments

    Oh geesh aroy3719 if you believe what you posted, then I've got a bridge in brooklyn, some swamp land in Alaska, and iceburg in florida to sell you.

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    RamoUrologyNurse2001

    9 months ago

    2 comments

    FRiends,what if one from us getting fat like this women,should we fired?Everybody have some predisposition,who s gonaa pass with help,medical help nd and strong ambition,i think that her colleagues have to help her nd give imp . adivices if they are indeed good md,before of all we are humans ,all of us,even if we r fat or slim s nd we have to help each other if it s in our power,and i m sure that she can get help from this side.In the same time ,yes,indeed is a source of infection nd this can be extremly dangerous for the pt,i think that ppls around her nd staff member have to give her a chance and remove her in other side.

  • Captain_topless_max50

    aroy3719

    9 months ago

    4 comments

    My best friend's neighbors dog walker's nephew knows the head-nurse of the Operating room at that hospital. She got fired when she dropped a triple cheeseburger with fries right into a chest cavity during open heart surgery... the patient was surprisingly pleasant about the whole affair, he commented that the reason he needed a quadruple bypass, and complete arterial replacement, was that he too loved triple bacon cheeseburgers. He said "don't sweat it," and she said... "too late for that". The bottom line is that while she perspired, he almost expired.

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    rippintaz

    9 months ago

    2 comments

    im not sure whos side im on here... i used to work in an assisted living faciliy ans an orderly/STNA, and i to sweat a HUGE amount! but i wasnt 300lbs..in fact i was a very healthy 185 (im male) only after i stopped taking the methadone i was on that i stopped sweating live crazy.. so maybe it was some med the woman was on? my sister was 300+ pounds and she didnt sweat like crazy.. so i really dont think it was due to this womans weight that got her fired most likely it was her weight. im sure that as many people that are in an OR during a surg. someone 300 pounds would take up the place of 2 adverage size people. she should have been transfered to another unit that her girth wouldnt be as much of an issue.

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    crazydaisy

    9 months ago

    4 comments

    Any hospital staff member could have referred her to a doctor that should have been able to help her with this "sweating" problem. Unless there are some other unpublished information not being made known to the public, it sounds to me that the sweat was just the EXCUSE the facility was using to terminate her because any of their other reasons could have got them in trouble for unlawful discharge of an employee.

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    dmazment

    9 months ago

    896 comments

    No ethyl, because most in the US are independent practitioners and since we've suddenly become customer service oriented, they're handled even more with kid gloves

  • Deb_004_max50

    ethyl

    9 months ago

    8 comments

    Do the doctors that sweat a lot get fired too?

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    PeacefulnightOwl

    9 months ago

    58 comments

    people should not be fired for excess sweating. Is there not a prescription that would help this condition? Why fire a valueable resourse ? This is beyond insane. Next we will fire nurses because of excessive flatulance. Gee wiz..... can they get any more rediculous???

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    dmazment

    9 months ago

    896 comments

    cdnurse if you're going to say she probably has body odor, it's not necessarily true. Yet, if she did, again I say, many of the surgeons should be right behind her being dismissed as care givers. The absolute worst perpetrators of breaks in sterile techniques and contamination in the OR are the surgeons and anesthesiologists. Those who scrub and circulate have a continuous battle with them to maintain the sterile fields. Circulating nurses do not or should not be closer to the sterile field than 18 inches. This is the minimal safe distance mandated by AORN here in the US. I was a travel nurse for over 12 years of my almost 30 years in the OR and it's the exact same problem through out the US. Very few of the OR's have the new air filtration systems, because most OR's are old and outdated.

    Yes it's a news article and many pertinent things have been left out. However, if taken at face value, it's discrimination.

  • Sunset_max50

    windy6606

    9 months ago

    6 comments

    I think we are finding a lot of closet obesiphobics. Those tiny size 0 girls who are in nursing to catch the doctor and fear they might catch the obesity if they get to close. I have worked with them for 34 years. But I have always been the better nurse. They are usually afraid to touch the patient, too. Sadly, hospitals fire nurses for all the wrong reasons anyway. No one seems to care except the nurse getting fired for something stupid.

What's the Scoop?

Post a link to something interesting from another site, or submit your own original writing for the NursingLink community to read.

Report News Here

Recent Activity

38519850840_max600_max30
jillrey_23 commented on: "Do You Have What It Takes to Be a Nurse?", 27 minutes ago.
Photo_user_blank_big
Bubblynurse commented on: "Patricia", 33 minutes ago.
38519850840_max600_max30
jillrey_23 posted in: "Micro and Human Anatomy and physiology", 33 minutes ago.
Photo_user_blank_big
nurselosh2009 commented on: "Labor and Delivery Nurse", 36 minutes ago.